function gtm_code() { ?>
close

The Many Meanings of Traceability: Ethics

Ask an accountant, a regulator, a roaster and a consumer what traceability means and you likely receive four different answers. We are looking at just one of those interpretations each time, and perhaps the Ethics side of it is the thorniest of all. The word ethics itself suffers from the same problem as traceability – it means different things to different people. From the very beginning we are on an uphill trajectory. But it’s not the first time the industry has risen to meet a challenge.

The industry has tried to address this in a number of ways. Certifications looked at inequalities and challenged these through making available products that would support a different outcome. Sold through churches and charity shops, they brought an ethical message as a counterpoint to the overly commercial alternative. However, the products did not always taste great and to a degree, there was a sacrifice from both the pocket and the cup to make the moral stance.

The early certifications had a built-in focus on the producing people. Pictures of the producers were on the label, stories were told about their poverty in adverts and the public were clearly shown what ethical looked like, and that it had a price. At the same time in the UK, from the 1990s and into the 2000s, coffee was having its moment as speciality was entering the market and coffee in general was garnering attention on the highstreets, countrywide. The public weren’t the only ones being educated about coffee, but the industry was too. There were no courses in the early days and low awareness of the word ‘barista’, let alone what that actually entailed.

What started to emerge were three different propositions. The ‘normal’ coffee, that was known and common. The ‘ethical’ option, which was tied to a price and a person, and the ‘speciality’ coffee that was focussed on the quality – and was more expensive.

Studies have been done looking at the certified approach, and their notes highlight changes in messaging. Just after the turn of the century, things got a little more confusing at a time when everything was still very unknown. The ethical pricing argument was still there, but the messaging was switching towards feeling good as a consumer for doing so.

This was part of a broader cultural phenomenon coined as ‘compassion fatigue’. Sixteen years after Live Aid, the method of messaging became somewhat of a trope and the charity sector was stepping away from the pitying period. Things changed towards a feel-good-by-doing-good type of messaging, and the faces in the pictures were switched from what was perceived as negative framing into a more dignified, smiling, grower.

This messaging landed on fertile ground with the speciality drinkers and their messaging of overlooked quality and recognition of the expertise of their farmers and producers. A positive message about recognition arriving at the same time as a familiar marketing message was changing whilst Joey, Phoebe, Rachel, Monica, Ross and Chandler were introducing us to coffee shops. Those coffee shops were introducing us to 5 panel menu boards and cups with names not sizes, drinks we’d never had before and origins we didn’t know grew coffee. You probably read that sentence twice. Is there any wonder we were confused when we were living it? There was enough going on that we shouldn’t be surprised if a couple of the more convenient elements collided.

What started to happen was price being the proof of the certified audit aligned with the more expensive product cost to become a ‘higher prices mean good ethics’ claim. Certainly, higher prices don’t exclude good ethics, but they don’t guarantee them in a supply chain that is not audited.

Let’s look at the market around those times. In 1989 the International Coffee Agreement had collapsed, and the market began to plummet. This is what the certifications were highlighting and trying to protect against. By the time they started to come in, the market was rising again off the back of historic frosts causing shortages in supply and demand. Coffee fell again, and that baseline made a huge difference to those that were in it. The case for price showing an ethical approach was made.

The market stayed low for a long time and steadily rose through those early noughties that speciality coffee was establishing itself. They paid more for the coffee because of the quality, and the logic that left itself open was if the market paid x, certification paid x+y, and speciality paid more than x+y, then it was even more ethical. The timing was spectacularly bad as the fall in the market was exactly when the messaging started to shift.

In a scene that was being learnt, very few were present to challenge it and so the message spread. Focussing on process methods, from a washed or a honey coffee, was easy to mix with a production method, being shade grown or organic. We didn’t help ourselves in the choice of language but that is just how things are sometimes.

Fast forward to today and that message has persisted. This is where the weakness shows. In a rising cost market, the maths is not the same and in some cases, the certifications are now more expensive than the speciality, or increasingly the exact same coffee. What does that say about the ethics?

The picture is further expanded by legal developments such as anti-greenwashing legislation and the Deforestation Regulation. Laudable end goals, but does a law protect or remove the ability to make an ethical claim? When all coffee is traceable by law, does it mean that everybody becomes equally ethical, or merely compliant? Both shift the conversation towards documented proof, with traceability increasingly providing the means to satisfy it. And what exactly are we including in our ethics now, pricing, environment, behaviour, security? Are we asking, listening, or telling?

Further adding to the mix is the CVA, where the extrinsic attributes are now there to help identify the practices, people and conditions as well as sustainability. The SCA’s own 2024 review of the research found Fair Trade certification and Organic certification among the extrinsic attributes that matter most to buyers. So, the new framework inherits the old proxies as inputs to value. Ethics as a term is not used explicitly, but is this the same as what the soft definition is held as?

If you dig into it here, the same argument is again repeated. You can record a farm gate price if you know it and be rewarded. But you do not know if that farm gate price is enough. Proprietary certifications are listed, as well as second- and third-party schemes. There is no requirement you be part of that orbit. Gender, age or social and environmental impact are also seen as worth gathering, compounding the link between a perceived ethical behaviour and value. Presumably, buying from a female farmer is beneficial, but only if you are actively promoting that to make sure you get the value. Does that prove you are actually open to support her and her needs though, or is this promoting tokenism?

There are many ways to look at it, dare we say, depending on your own ethics. If a supplier is visible, scrutiny becomes possible, improvement becomes possible, relationships become possible. Visibility on its own doesn’t guarantee any of the rest follows or any combination of its parts either. Scrutiny on its own is not a relationship, and a relationship is not the same as improvement. They don’t even need to be. Perhaps this is why value and not ethics is being promoted now. But as much with the coffee chain, the further down you move, the harder the nuances are to tease apart/comprehend.

We return to the EU anti Greenwashing laws. For these are seeking to remove some of this grey area from coffee. And to a degree, they have already. A quick internet search will no longer show ‘Sugarcane Natural’ as a marketing term as much as it used to when it first appeared. The chemical solvent used to decaffeinate the bean may be allowed to be described as natural as it was derived from sugarcane. But using that chemical to then remove the caffeine from green coffee removes the ability to call the coffee natural. A chemical process has still taken place.

So perhaps of all of the readings for traceability, using it as a proxy for ethics is the most confusing of all. For quality or regulation, we are fairly aligned as to what the confusion is because the alternative is somewhat binary. For ethics, it has as many interpretations based upon each individual views as ethical and so many more gaps to fall through.